It wasn’t until the late 1800s that lobster gained the rapt attention of high society and formed an unbreakable power couple with hot melted butter. Of course, the Caribbean never needed to be convinced about the virtues of decadent decapod. The quiet and dreamy island of Anguilla is widely known throughout the region, both for the quality of its lobster and its cuisine.
If you’re a lobster lover, you simply must try it in Anguilla.
That’s because – in contrast to other Caribbean islands – Anguilla’s lobster season is all year round. The blue waters of Anguilla teem with Spiny lobsters, which may look a little different than what you are used to, but are even more delicious than what you’d find in the seafood section of your local grocery store.
While just about every eatery across the island offers their sizzling take on freshly caught lobster, here are three of our favourites to get your mouth watering:
Sandy Island
This offshore cay, accessible via ferry from the bustling (by Anguillian standards) Sandy Ground, is not only a great place to spend the day lounging on your own private island: it also serves up classically grilled lobster, pulled right from the ocean.
Aurora Anguilla
This 5-star hotel and golf club is also known for its elevated culinary offerings, which include a weekly, unlimited lobster and crayfish buffet. Enjoy live music and the idyllic beachfront setting as you fill plate after plate with premium Anguillian lobster.
Jacala
Set on unbelievably scenic Meads Bay, Jacala comes highly recommended by foodies. This sophisticated yet laid-back gem is right on the sand, and guests can’t stop raving about their lobster club sandwich, the perfect marriage of carbs and crustacean!
Where to Stay in Anguilla
Whether you’re here for the lobster or just the view, Anguilla has places to stay that match every mood—from ultra-luxe to quietly charming.
Aurora Anguilla Resort & Golf Club
If you’re already heading here for the lobster buffet, why not stay the night—or several? Aurora offers elegant beachfront suites, a Greg Norman-designed golf course, and a world-class spa. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your name, and your drink order.
Zemi Beach House
On Shoal Bay East, Zemi blends upscale comfort with a more boutique feel. Think: barefoot luxury, modern Caribbean design, and a Thai-inspired spa set inside a 300-year-old house. Ideal for couples or solo travelers looking to decompress.
Carimar Beach Club
For something more low-key (but still right on the beach), Carimar on Meads Bay is a longtime favorite. It’s not flashy, but it’s got everything you need—spacious villas, friendly staff, and prime access to Jacala and other top spots.
You can learn more about Anguilla at https://ivisitanguilla.com/.
